You have probably heard the common advice in podcasting: come up with a title that is so descriptive and clear that anyone could accurately guess what your show is about simply from the title alone. That is excellent advice, but it is more of a guideline than an absolute law. To borrow a thought from the Pirates of the Caribbean movies, the rules of podcasting are sometimes more like guidelines anyway.
If you look at almost any list of top podcasts, whether it is a chart in a podcast app, a curated list, or the New and Noteworthy section, you will find shows of varying degrees of success with clever, cute, or completely unique titles. These titles do not directly describe what the podcast is about, yet the shows thrive.
While standard podcast SEO relies on clear and obvious naming, there are specific scenarios where breaking the mold makes sense. Let us explore exactly when it makes sense to favor creativity over pure searchability.
1. When Clever Podcast Titles Have Clarifying Subtitles
Using a clever or unique title is perfectly okay in Apple Podcasts and other directories when you pair it with a clarifying subtitle. This allows you to have a name that hardcore fans will instantly recognize, while still ensuring people can find your show when searching for your main topic. The key is that the subtitle must clarify the subject matter, not just serve as a tagline full of keyword stuffing. A tagline makes a promise about what your podcast delivers, whereas a clarifying subtitle simply explains the actual title.
A clarifying subtitle is also extremely helpful when a purely descriptive title risks trademark infringement. For example, you cannot legally name your show “The Microsoft Podcast” without securing the tech giant's wrath. However, you can use a creative name and include the brand in your clarifying subtitle. I learned this firsthand with my TV show fan podcast about Once Upon a Time. The official name of our podcast was simply Once, but after a friendly yet serious conversation with a Disney lawyer regarding potential brand confusion, we adjusted the podcast app title to “Once – Unofficial Once Upon a Time Podcast.”
Adding that clarifying subtitle kept us out of legal trouble while satisfying Apple's guidelines against egregious keyword stuffing. Some podcasters try to cram theories, character names, and dozens of keywords into their titles until they hit an algorithm trigger point and get kicked out of Apple Podcasts.
Avoiding keyword stuffing while finding the perfect clarifying term allows you to legally and effectively capture search traffic. Understanding how to balance this overall searchability leads right into how we look at titles on a micro level for individual episodes.
2. When Clever Episode Titles Are for Entertainment-Based Podcasts
Sometimes your overall podcast title is perfectly clear, but your individual episode titles are cute, clever, or somewhat mysterious. This strategy works remarkably well for entertainment-based podcasts where your primary goal is to make your audience laugh or spark deep curiosity. A weird or clever episode title can actually strengthen the connection you have with your existing audience, serving as an inside joke that pays off once they listen.
When your listeners finally reach the point in the conversation where the clever title was born, they get that satisfying moment where they realize where the name of the episode came from. While it is true that these obscure titles will not attract new listeners through search engines, an entertainment podcast does not always have to prioritize standard SEO. If you have a comedy podcast, a vanilla title like “The Episode Where We Talk About Childhood Stories” is not very compelling. A mysterious, funny inside joke is far more likely to get your current audience to press play.
For informational or educational shows like The Audacity to Podcast, I rely heavily on search engine optimization and use clear, descriptive titles based on what people are actually asking. But if your show is designed purely to entertain, the title itself should be part of the entertainment package.
Of course, whether you are trying to be entertaining or just highly distinctive, there are times when your overall branding must take priority over SEO.
3. When Uniqueness Is More Important Than Podcast SEO
Imagine you are launching a podcast about a massive cultural phenomenon like Stranger Things. If you name your show “The Stranger Things Podcast,” you are instantly competing with dozens of others using that exact same generic name. When you tell someone to search for it, they will be greeted by a wall of similar titles, and you will have to over-explain which specific cover art to look for. By prioritizing uniqueness over SEO, you could name your show something distinctive like “Hawkins Radio” or “The Upside Downcast.”
Those unique terms are instantly recognizable to fans of the show, and you can still include “Stranger Things” as a clarifying subtitle so you do not lose out entirely on search traffic. When you have a distinctive name, it is far easier for listeners to find the exact right show when searching their podcast app. Furthermore, a highly unique name gives you the ability to legally protect your brand. Generic names are incredibly difficult, if not impossible, to trademark.
I have always valued unique branding, which is why I have successfully trademarked names like The Audacity to Podcast, Podgagement, and most recently, PodChapters. “PodChapters” is distinctive enough to be legally protected. If I had simply named it “Podcast Chapters,” it would be far too generic to secure a trademark.
Being unique helps you stand out and protect your intellectual property, but what if your title is completely obscure and lacks any clarifying subtitles? That is when you need a massive promotional push.
4. When Clever-Titled Podcasts Have Amazing Marketing
There are plenty of highly successful podcasts out there that have zero descriptive elements in their titles. If you look at the top charts in Apple Podcasts, you will see shows like The Daily, Pod Save America, Up First, and The Joe Rogan Experience. None of these titles tell a new listener exactly what the show is about. In fact, Joe Rogan's podcast does not even have a clearly defined topic; his unique conversational style and approach are the actual niche.
These shows dominate the charts not because their titles are search-friendly, but because they have incredible marketing engines behind them. Consider the massive hit podcast Serial. Before its release, if you heard someone was launching a podcast called Serial, you probably would have assumed it was a show about breakfast foods like Cheerios or Apple Jacks. It was a terrible title for standard podcast SEO, but the phenomenal marketing and word-of-mouth promotion completely made up for it. And don't fall into the trap of thinking, “It's not hurting their podcast!”
We see this exact same phenomenon in the tech world. When Apple changed the name of their laptops from PowerBook to MacBook, or when they launched the iPad, people initially mocked the names. However, Apple threw so much marketing power behind those products that the names are now just common vernacular. If you have the budget or the platform to promote heavily, you can use whatever clever podcast title you want and let your marketing do the heavy lifting.
A massive marketing budget solves a lot of naming issues, but even if you do not have millions of dollars, you can still strategically employ clever titles by remembering these foundational ideas.
If you love The Audacity to Podcast and value the podcasting inspiration and education I provide, would you please consider giving back what it's worth to you?
Supercharge your podcast engagement and grow your podcast!
Do you ever feel like your podcast is stuck? Like you're pouring your heart into your podcast but it seems like no one is listening?
Try Podgagement to help you supercharge your podcast endgagement!
Get speakable pages to simplify engaging with your audience, accept voicemail feedback (with automatic transcripts), see and share your ratings and reviews from nearly 200 places, follow your podcast rankings across nearly 34,000 global charts, discover networking opportunities, and more!
Ask your questions or share your feedback
- Comment on the episode
- Send a written or voicemail message here
Follow The Audacity to Podcast
- Apple Podcasts, Spotify, other Android apps, or in your favorite podcast app.
- Subscribe on YouTube for Podcasting Videos by The Audacity to Podcast
- Follow @theDanielJLewis on X-Twitter
Disclosure
This post may contain links to products or services with which I have an affiliate relationship. I may receive compensation from your actions through such links. However, I don't let that corrupt my perspective and I don't recommend only affiliates.
Related Content
