TAP011: Podcasting with Software Compressors vs. Hardware Compressors

  • Share:
  • Check-in on GetGlue
  • Share:
  • Check-in on GetGlue
Play

Compression, expansion, noise gate, threshold, ratio—what does it all mean? Should you use a software audio compressor like Chris’s Dynamic Compressor, or a hardware compressor connected to your mixer? Also get an Audacity quick tip for seeing, at a glance, where your audio clips and distorts.

Please support our content

We have expenses for our podcasts. Please look at these options for how you can support us by supporting our sponsors (or outright hiring me).

  • Make your message look great by hiring me to personally design your website, presentation, podcast cover art, and more! Visit D.Joseph Design to view my portfolio and request an estimate.
  • Save money by shopping at Amazon.com.

Understanding compressor terminology

  • Compression—from the top down, sometimes from the bottom up
  • Expansion—expands the range of low volume, opposition of compression, quiets small audio
  • Gate—Opens and closes to allow or prevent audio
  • Threshold—the point above which audio is compressed
  • Ratio—how much to compress audio
  • Peak limiter—hard wall to prevent audio from exceeding a volume
  • Attack and release (hard and soft knee)—How fast to approach and dissolve the compression, “interactive knee” will change the attack and release speed depending on the input volume

Simple to complex compressors

Levelator (free, standalone)—no options Mixer-based compressor knob (built into some mixers)—just a single knob, like on my Behringer Xenyx X1832USB. Chris’s Dynamic Compressor (free, standalone and Audacity plugin)—a few simple options, follow his instructions to unlock the advanced options Hardware compressor/limiter/gate ($80 and up, standalone device)—several knobs, some have more options than others. Such as my Behringer MDX4600 (currently $120). C3 Multiband Compressor (free, plugin with Audacity edition) or Adobe Audition‘s Multiband Compressor (included plugin with $349 software)

Should you use a software or hardware compressor?

Robert from It’s Just Us has a Alesis 3630 Compressor Dynamics Processor and Adobe Audition 2.0 and wanted to know whether he should use the hardware or software compressor. The short answer is that you have to decide for yourself based on the advantages and disadvantages that affect you.

Software compressor advantages

  1. Free
  2. Edit undestructively after recording
  3. Experiment with the same audio to see and hear changes
  4. Compress audio from any source: studio mics, field recordings, or sound clips
  5. Often has presets to reduce complexity
  6. Forward-looking compression

Software disadvantages

  1. Not real-time
  2. Extra steps
  3. Extra processing time
  4. Processes all or nothing
  5. The tools may change (Audacity, Audition, Soundbooth, Pro Logic, etc.)

Hardware advantages

  1. Channel isolation
    • Individualized setttings for each host
    • Preventing noise in other tracks
    • Compressing only what you want (voices, not music)
  2. Process in real-time for fast turnaround
  3. Live audience benifits

Hardware disadvantages

  1. Expensive ($80 and up)
  2. May require other upgrades, such as getting a mixer with inserts
  3. Different settings depending on content
  4. Mistakes are baked into the recording
  5. No presets

Conclusion

If you’re just starting out with audio compression, stick with a software compressor so you can learn as you experiment. Always keep and unprocessed archive of your recording. If you have extra money and want to optimize your workflow and have almost instant turnaround, get a hardware compressor.

No live shows for a while

I’m getting married! Although I will have prerecorded episodes still released on a schedule, this was the last live recording for a while. After I’m married, I may rearrange the Ramen Noodle™ and The Audacity to Podcast™ to be live on the same night.

Do you have questions?

Please ask your questions or share your thoughts here in the comments, email [email protected], or call our listener voicemail line at (903) 231-2221.

Also follow me on Twitter and please consider leaving a five-star review for the show in iTunes.

You can contact me through the same methods if you’re interested in my design, production, or consultation services.

If you enjoy The Audacity to Podcast™, please subscribe to our other podcasts on the Noodle.mx Network: Are You Just Watching?™ and the Ramen Noodle™.

Related posts

  1. TAP005: My Secret Audacity Recipe for Great Audio
  2. TAP003: The Bare Minimums for Podcasting
  3. TAP004: Live-Podcasting Questions and Answers
  4. TAP010: Audacity and iTunes—Making Not-LAME MP3s
  5. TAP007: Changing iTunes Author Name, Cover Art, and Waveform Visualization
  • http://www.airplanegeeks.com/ Max Flight

    This was a great episode – plenty of really good information to help make a more informed decision about the best approach to compression. I've been using Levelator for quite some time and I'm generally pleased with it. It's certainly a "no-brainer" when it comes to running it – just drag the wav file over it and let it go.

    Doing the same for listener v-mails that come in through Google Voice is very helpful also. Lately I've started running a little noise removal on them first with Audacity, exporting them to a wav file, and then through Levelator. They sound clearer when I then play the v-mails during the show.

  • anewsome

    I *LOVE* Chris’s Dynamic Compressor! Thank you for telling me about this. I've been using it every since this episode of TAP aired. I would love to know if you have more of these type plug-ins that I could use to make my sound even better. I use Audacity all the time for my show (record to a digital recorder in WAV) to edit when/if necessary and I love learning how to use it better.

    Thanks for taking time to do these shows. (Thanks to your wife, too.) –Allan

    • http://noodle.mx Daniel Lewis

      That's great to hear! I have on my list to review the latest version of Chris's Dynamic Compressor, and I've actually been trying to get Chris on the podcast sometime.

      This next episode will be really fun!

  • Pingback: 005 | The Bunker Project – Social Broadcasters and Agregators | Podcast Hero