Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Don't get discouraged when something goes terribly wrong and you're ashamed to release something you've recorded. Try the following tips for handling these potentially embarrassing mistakes in podcasting.
My recent failure
I attended the 2014 Consumer Electronics Show (CES2014) to cover it with The TechPodcasts Network. This was my second time and I had a lot better perspective on what I should cover, how to look for things, and what to expect.
I had a lot of fun, especially since I wasn't sick as CES2014. In 2013, I recorded only three floor interviews, but I lost two of them and the remaining one wasn't interesting enough to be my only video. In 2014, I recorded nearly twenty videos and I thought I got some great content and found unique products.
But upon returning home and starting to edit the videos, I discovered that the mic gain wasn't set properly and all but one of my videos had terrible audio. This was my crisis. Should I release these videos when I'm ashamed of their audio quality?
Yes, I will release the videos anyway. You can watch them here on The Audacity to Podcast's website, on my YouTube channel, or in my iTunes video feed.
Since I know I'm not the only one who can mess up so painfully, here are some tips to help you overcome the “podcast failure blues.”
1. Redo, if possible
When it is at all possible, my top suggestion is to redo your episode. Yes, this means more time. But it may actually take less time to fully re-record than to fix all the problems.
This can be really embarrassing to ask a your cohost or especially a special guest for a do-over. Generally, they'll be understanding, especially when the do-over is so they will look better. If you have to ask for this, be humble, apologetic, and extremely flexible. If your special guest suggests a time, you move heaven and earth to make that happen so you'll inconvenience them the least.
Sometimes, a redo means losing a magical moment that could only be so genuine on the first take. If that's the case, you could consider releasing that as a bonus somewhere, or attached to the end of your episode.
There have been several episodes of The Audacity to Podcast that I felt horrible about my presentation of the content. When I redid these episodes, the results were much better and I was glad that I took the extra time.
2. Don't start with an apology
If you have to publish a “failure,” don't treat it as a failure. One of the worst opening lines is “I'm sorry.” This will distract your audience by drawing even more attention to the mistakes.
Sometimes, your audience won't even notice the “failure” or won't consider it to be that bad if you never point out that it exists. This isn't dishonesty; it's pushing the most important thing forward.
Movie mistakes happen all the time (like the storm trooper who banged his head in one of the original Star Wars movies, or the minivan that wasn't masked out in Gettysburg, and much more). But you never hear the director apologize. You may have not even noticed the problems if no one ever pointed them out.
Remember that your audience will be generally forgiving if this is a rare occasion.
3. Fix it the best you can
You have to press on with what you got, but it's still embarrassing. This is where you may want to invest the time to fix it the best you can. If the audio is horrible (like my CES2014 videos), try to fix it, enhance it, or at least make the problems less prominent. If the video seems unusable, consider covering it up with secondary or supporting footage (B-roll), even if you have to make it up new (screenshots, slides, video of the item, etc.).
Fixing problems can take a lot of time and they'll never make “garbage” beautiful again. But they can at least make “garbage” stink a little less.
You may have to partially redo your recording in order to fix a problem. Here are a few examples.
- If your audio was bad but your guest's was good, re-record just your parts, the best that you can.
- Change your video to a documentary style with voiceovers or primarily your thoughts in studio.
- Release the content in a completely different way. Such as audio if your video was bad, or written if the audio is unusable.
Be careful not to fix things too much so that it seems artificial or you introduce new problems (like the “underwater” sound when you remove too much noise).
4. Skip, if it's too bad
If it's completely impossible to redo or fix and it's far too embarrassing to release, you could consider skipping it altogether. This is the nuclear option that you may not be as necessary as you think.
Before you decide to completely scrap what you have, look at the big picture, give it a day, or get someone else's opinion.
5. Ensure it doesn't happen again
No matter how you handle the podcast failure, learn as much as you can from them so you can prevent the problem in the future. This may mean changing the way you do things or adding new steps to ensure quality for next time.
My CES2014 failure could have been avoided if I had done a test video and checked it before recording. Even if you're confident in your setup and workflow, a short test can always be re-assuring, especially if it's right before a big opportunity.
You may even need to invest in better or extra equipment in order to prevent the problem next time.
Learn from some of my mistakes and how I changed to prevent them from coming back.
- When I had my first recording-into-my-PC failure (because I did something stupid and overstressed my PC), I immediately bought my external recorder to reduce the chances of failure.
- When I kept repeating the mistake of not pressing my record button, I moved my recorder to a more visible location.
- When my camera's focus went crazy in one of my videos, I stopped relying on automatic controls and switched to manual. I also often do a short test and check it on my PC before starting production.
- I'll soon buy “cough buttons” for my cohosts so they can mute themselves if they need it.
Also remember that every “failure” could be a step toward success. If it helped you learn something, was it really a failure? (Check out my interview on Bruce Naylor's Business Computer Weekly when he asked me about my past failures.)
Have you had an embarrassing podcast moment? How did you work through it and press on? Please comment on the shownotes to share your story!
Podcasters' Roundtable: Should your podcast have an app?
With the popularity of mobile devices and mobile apps, there are plenty of podcast apps out there. But should your podcast have it's own, standalone app? Check out our Podcasters' Roundtable with Ray Ortega, Dave Jackson, Rob Walsh, Chase Nunes, Kevin Scullion, and me as we debate this idea and discuss benefits and disadvantages.
We also recorded a roundtable live at New Media Expo on, ironically, “Are conferences worth it?”
Last chance for the February Podcast Master Class!
If you want to take your podcast from average to amazing, now is your last chance to register for Podcast Master Class in February! This will be a hard-knocks class to make your existing podcast much better. We'll talk about business, profit, promotion, production, and much more. This is also your chance for a 100-point evaluation of your podcast to discover what's hurting you and your high-priority actions to improve.
Listen to this podcast episode for an exclusive promo code to save on your Podcast Master Class registration!
Need personalized podcasting help?
I no longer offer one-on-one consulting outside of Podcasters' Society, but request a consultant here and I'll connect you with someone I trust to help you launch or improve your podcast.
Ask your questions or share your feedback
- Comment on the shownotes
- Leave a voicemail at (903) 231-2221
- Email feedback@TheAudacitytoPodcast.com (audio files welcome)
Connect with me
- Subscribe to The Audacity to Podcast on Apple Podcasts or on Android.
- Join the Facebook Page and watch live podcasting Q&A on Mondays at 2pm (ET)
- Subscribe on YouTube for video reviews, Q&A, and more
- Follow @theDanielJLewis
This post may contain links to products or services with which I have an affiliate relationship and may receive compensation from your actions through such links. However, I don't let that corrupt my perspective and I don't recommend only affiliates.
Daniel, here is an idea I have been thinking about using, but have not needed yet. It may help your CES audio issue. The normal workflow for noise removal would be to capture the noise print, then run the noise reduction. For serious noise situations, how about capture the noise print, then run a noise gate (suppressing the noise in between the talking), then run the noise removal. You would not need to run the noise removal so aggressively that it makes you sound tinny because the noise gate would have reduced the noise level where it is most obvious. Also, you may get better results from running a slight gate several times rather than running it aggressively all at once.
That’s a good idea. But the problem with prominent noise is that a noise gate would yield a “punchy” sound. In some ways, the noise would be less noticable if it was a constant than if it was in and out with every word or sentence.Faithfully,
Daniel J. Lewis
Grow your podcast from average to amazing! http://PodcastMasterClass.com
My big podcasting failure became a regular segment in our podcast! We did an episode for my Strangers and Aliens podcast — http://strangersandaliens.com — that involved using old time radio shows. But the audio for our Skype recording that episode was so bad, I decided not to use that episode with the intention to re-record later.
We forgot to re-record, but over a year later we ended up releasing it as a “lost episode.” Lost, of course, because I was not happy with the audio. People liked it, and that format of presenting and commenting on old time radio episodes is something we’ve turned into a series of special episodes within our podcast!
Sometime, check out the clean-comedy podcast “Bell’s in the Batfry.” He did some audio dramas making fun of old-time radio.